Skip to content
MyFreud

Treating insomnia in pregnancy brought gains beyond sleep

Two insomnia therapies tested in pregnancy also cut bedtime procrastination and anxiety and lifted positive mood, none of which they had been aiming at.

2 min read

Pop-art illustration of a woman sitting up in bed between two lit bedside lamps.

Key takeaways

  • Both treatments produced large drops in bedtime procrastination, the habit of putting off going to bed despite being tired.
  • Positive mood rose, while negative mood did not fall. Those are separate things, and the first is the one that moved.
  • Only the mindfulness programme reduced rumination about sleep. Standard CBT for insomnia did not.
  • Sixty-four participants across three arms is small, and these were secondary outcomes rather than what the trial was built to measure.

Sleep problems in pregnancy get treated as scenery. They are common, they are expected, and the standard response is that this is what pregnancy is like. A trial published in Sleep advances in 2026 looked at what happens when you treat them properly anyway, and found the benefits ran wider than sleep. [pubmed-sleep-jun-2026-source]

What the researchers did

Sixty-four pregnant women with clinical insomnia were randomly assigned to one of three arms: cognitive behavioural therapy for insomnia, a mindfulness-based programme designed for pregnancy called PUMAS, or sleep hygiene education as the comparison.

This particular paper is a secondary analysis. The trial’s main question was whether the treatments improved insomnia, which is reported elsewhere. What this analysis asks is what else moved: bedtime procrastination, rumination about sleep, anxiety, mood, and mindfulness.

What they found

Both active treatments produced large reductions in bedtime procrastination, the familiar business of staying up despite being tired and knowing better.

Both produced clear gains in positive affect: interest, enthusiasm, feeling engaged rather than flat. Notably, negative affect did not fall. Those are separate dimensions rather than opposite ends of one scale, and only one of them moved.

Among participants who had anxiety symptoms to begin with, both treatments produced large reductions in anxiety.

The one clean difference between the two treatments: the mindfulness programme reduced rumination about sleep, the lying-awake-thinking-about-not-sleeping loop, and standard CBT for insomnia did not. Neither improved general mindfulness skills as measured.

How much weight to give it

Sixty-four people across three groups is roughly twenty per arm, which is small. Everything reported here is a secondary outcome, and secondary outcomes in small trials are where chance findings gather. The effect sizes are large, but large effects estimated from small samples are also the least stable.

The comparison condition was sleep hygiene education, which is a fair active control, though it is also widely regarded as the weakest of the sleep interventions.

Treat the direction as informative and the magnitudes as provisional.

What this means in practice

Two things are worth taking from it.

Insomnia in pregnancy is a treatable problem rather than a feature of the territory, and the treatments are behavioural rather than pharmacological, which matters when medication options are limited.

And the gains people actually notice may not be the ones on the sleep questionnaire. Feeling engaged again, and stopping the nightly delay before bed, are the changes participants would describe if asked how they were doing.

Is bedtime procrastination part of your problem?

Tick anything true of most evenings in the last month.

0 of 6 ticked

The source

These findings are drawn from “Treating insomnia during pregnancy improves bedtime procrastination, rumination, anxiety, and positive affect: a randomized controlled trial of cognitive-behavioral and mindfulness-based therapies for prenatal insomnia” (Kalmbach DA, Reffi AN, Cheng P, et al., 2026), published in Sleep advances. Read the full study on PubMed.

Frequently asked questions

What is bedtime procrastination?

Delaying going to bed when nothing is stopping you, while knowing you are tired and will regret it. It is one of the more relatable findings in sleep research because almost everyone recognises it, and it is usually less about sleep than about reclaiming a stretch of unclaimed time at the end of the day. That makes it a plausible thing for therapy to shift, since the obstacle is not physiological.

Why does positive mood rising matter if negative mood did not fall?

Because they are genuinely distinct rather than two ends of one scale. You can be less flat and dull without being less anxious or irritable, and vice versa. Positive affect covers interest, enthusiasm and feeling engaged, which is often what people mean when they say they feel like themselves again. That it moved while negative affect did not is a specific, believable finding rather than a general glow.

Is insomnia in pregnancy something to treat rather than endure?

Yes, and treating it is the mainstream position rather than a novel one. Insomnia is common in pregnancy and is associated with poorer mood and worse outcomes, and non-drug treatments are preferred because medication options are constrained. The habit of writing off pregnancy sleep problems as inevitable is the thing this research argues against.

Should I choose the mindfulness version over standard CBT?

This trial is too small to make that call, and it gives you one distinguishing data point: the mindfulness arm reduced rumination about sleep and the CBT arm did not. If lying awake mentally litigating your own sleep is the dominant feature of your nights, that difference is at least worth mentioning when discussing options. Both produced comparable gains elsewhere.

References

  1. 1.Kalmbach DA, Reffi AN, Cheng P, et al. ( 2026). Treating insomnia during pregnancy improves bedtime procrastination, rumination, anxiety, and positive affect: a randomized controlled trial of cognitive-behavioral and mindfulness-based therapies for prenatal insomnia. Sleep advances : a journal of the Sleep Research Society. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov . doi:10.1093/sleepadvances/zpag050